Tommy Karole brings his signature warmth and culinary creativity southward to Kitty Hawk with this casually stylish spot located at milepost 4.5 on the Bypass.

The Pony and the Boat—named after Lyle Lovett’s song "If I Had a Boat"—serves up fresh spins on classic comfort dishes, crafted as if Mom herself were a chef dedicated to premium ingredients and imaginative preparation. This Kitty Hawk gem offers ultra-satisfying and occasionally surprising takes on chicken pot pie, fried chicken, local Outer Banks seafood, pot roast, and standout Southern-style sides. With options for everyone, including vegans, vegetarians, and kids, it’s comfort food perfected, best enjoyed with a glass of wine, an N.C. craft beer, a signature cocktail, or a choice from their extensive bourbon list.

A Kitty Hawk Restaurant with Neighborhood Charm The Pony and the Boat Comfort Kitchen invites guests into a warm, inviting atmosphere, featuring reclaimed barn wood and yakisugi-treated accents. Highlights include a fireplace, abundant natural light, and an inverted rowboat suspended from the cathedral ceiling in the main dining area. The space combines stainless steel touches, subtle lighting, and soothing blues in a spacious bar area, giving it the laid-back yet refined feel of a contemporary neighborhood pub. Choose a seat at the bar, a cozy booth, or the open main dining area, where tables can accommodate both intimate gatherings and larger groups